Sunday, August 3, 2014

Let's Make a D.O.K.! A Game Show Approach to Depth of Knowledge

What exactly is depth of knowledge?

Questioning with Webb's Depth of Knowledge
The framework designed by Norman Webb (1997) categorizes depth of knowledge into four levels. 

D.O.K.-1 questions require students  to recall or reproduce knowledge and/or skills to come up with an answer that is either correct or incorrect.  Questions at this particular level usually involves working with facts, terms, and/or properties of objects.

D.O.K.-2 questions expect students to think deeper about how to answer questions by applying the knowledge and skills they have acquired and developed.  Such teaching and learning experiences involve students working with or applying skills and/or concepts to tasks related to the field of study in a laboratory setting.  They also require students to follow a set of principles, categories, and protocols in order to answer a question, address a problem, or accomplish a task. 

A D.O.K.-3 question challenges students to think critically and strategically how to answer a question acceptably, accurately, appropriately, and authentically.  They challenge and engage students to demonstrate and communicate higher levels of thinking such as analysis and evaluation but also communicate their thinking and reasoning behind their responses and results.

A D.O.K.-4 question engages students to examine and explore concepts and content deeply and think creatively how they can use their knowledge, understanding, and awareness to answer questions or come up with new ideas, knowledge, perspectives, and ways of thinking about what they are learning.  Such questions encourage students to examine and explore how to address, handle, settle, or solve real world circumstances, issues, problems, and situations through research, investigation, experimentation, and creative design.  They also expect students to express and share their claims, conclusions, decisions, and reasons using oral, written, creative, and technical expression. 

Sounds simple, right?

Then why is there so much confusion as to what qualifies as deeper knowledge, understanding, thinking, and awareness?  

Why is there so much concern over how students' depth of knowledge of concepts and content will be assessed and evaluated on assessments such as the PARCC or the Smarter Balanced exams?  

How would you explain this academic concept to a new teacher who has just entered the profession or moved from a state that had not adopted the Common Core State Standards?

How would you explain this cognitive schema to a veteran teacher who is used to aligning their instruction to the categories within the Cognitive Domain of Bloom's Taxonomy or its revised version which has split knowledge into its own dimension?

How would you explain this instructional focus to parents and students who for years have been instructed, assessed, and evaluated based upon how much they know, understand, and can do rather than how deeply they know, understand, and aware of a concept or content in order to answer a question, address a problem, or accomplish a task?

How can we develop instructional activities and assessments that not only stimulate student thinking and deepen their knowledge, understanding, and awareness about what they are learning but also measure and monitor the level of thinking and depth of knowledge they can demonstrate and communicate?

We can teach them like game show contestants.

Now wait a minute.  I'm not suggesting we turn our classroom into entertainment centers in which students compete with their classmates as to who can answer questions, address problems, or accomplish tasks correctly or successfully for a prize or reward.  I'm suggesting that they can use the format of questions, problems, and tasks on various game shows to challenge and engage students to demonstrate and communicate different levels of knowledge, understanding, thinking, and awareness.

D.O.K.-1 activities generally resemble the kind of questions contestants are asked on Who Wants to Be a Millionaire or Jeopardy - multiple choice or short answer questions that require demonstrating and communicating factual knowledge of specific details, elements, and information correctly.  The questions asked on Jeopardy are similar to how we assess and evaluate our students' factual, procedural, and conceptual knowledge of the subjects and topics they are learning - asking them to recall, recognize, and remember specific details, elements, facts and information correctly.   Such questions are more difficult than complex, requiring students to work hard at remembering so many details correctly, which is why Who Wants to Be a Millionaire and Jeopardy are two of the most difficult game shows on the air.  However, such questions can help students develop the knowledge and understanding they will need to think deeper about what they are learning. 

D.O.K.-2 activities are similar to the competitive tasks presented on shows such as Top Chef or Hell's Kitchen in which contestants expected to use conceptual and procedural knowledge to answer a question, address a problem, or accomplish a task.  These shows are like a lab experience in which students actively apply their knowledge, understanding, and skills to complete and are evaluated based upon their ability to produce a correct, desired, or specific result.  It expects students to use what they have learned to answer a question, address a problem, or accomplish a task.  As with Hell's Kitchen and Top Chef, D.O.K.-2 questions focus heavily on skills-based performance, expecting students to demonstrate their ability to use the factual, conceptual, and procedural knowledge they have acquired in a specific area, discipline, or subject.

D.O.K.-3 activities are similar to the problems and tasks presented on game shows such as Survivor or The Apprentice  Both shows are prime examples of problem-based learning that challenges students to think critically and strategically about how to answer a question, address a problem, or accomplish a task.  They also emphasize collaboration in that the questions, problems, and tasks posed, presented, and provided cannot be answered, addressed, or accomplished alone or immediately.  D.O.K.-3 activities are like the competitions on Survivor and the tasks on The Apprentice in that they are highly complex and focus more on the process in which a question, problem, or task can be answered, addressed, or accomplished.

D.O.K.-4 activities are like Shark Tank, which essentially is project-based learning and even engineering design.  A person thinks creatively about how to design and develop an innovative or inventive plan or product that addresses a particular circumstance, issue, problem, or situation; plots out the plan or produces a prototype; tests their idea or design; and then presents their conclusions to a panel, defending, explaining, and justifying their reasoning and results.  Project-based learning should mirror the experience of Shark Tank in that students should be expected to present what they have designed, developed, or done and have their project evaluated by the teacher and their peers as to whether it answers the essential question of the unit or class, addresses a particular objective, and teaches them something new about the concept or content they are learning.

So when you are planning your D.O.K. activities this year, consider which game show your question, problem, or task will appear and how it expects to students to demonstrate and communicate their thinking - and let's make a D.O.K.!
- E.M.F.



  1. Thanks for sharing this educational games. This form of writing is known as KSA – knowledge skills abilities and it refers to the elements of all three that you believe you have that make you the best person to hire for the job.

  2. KSA writer services from us always a great help for you in many ways besides being cost effective in addition for you. Our experienced KSA writer services are quite easy to avail with our online order form and your tasks will be resolved quickly.
    writing ksa

  3. Great article! I really enjoyed your analogy and found it easy to help teachers understand DOK. Thanks for sharing.

  4. Excellent article. Thank you very much. It clarifies a lot of notions I had regarding the teaching/learning process.

  5. This is fantastic. I've seen many schools struggle with how to interpret and work with DOK. This is the first game show approach. It really illuminates. I'm most familiar with schools that say:
    1. Gets idea or some approximation of idea
    2. Master relevant vocabulary
    3. Can do the skill as stated by standard
    4. Can apply skill amidst real complexity and work with its implications.

    I'm not saying that this is the right (or only) use of DOK. I'm saying that is the one that I see most commonly used in my local school district.

    I'm working on a blog post with some real statistics on this at

  6. Great Post! Used this activity in our high school staff meeting yesterday....THANKS!

  7. Everyday academic challenges make every student face a set of certain problems. These problems in the first place deal with the importance of choosing the proper theme for an academic paper in the first place and making it creative in the second place. See more ksa answers

  8. I really enjoyed your analogy and found it easy to help teachers understand DOK. Thanks for sharing.
    gclub จีคลับ
    gclub casino

  9. I really enjoyed your analogy and found it easy to help teachers understand DOK. Thanks for sharing.
    Run 4 Cat Ninja Ludo Star

  10. Very nice post
    Thanks for this news
    Thanks a lot
    Love you sir

  11. ร้อยไหม
    ร้อยไหมปรับรูปหน้า ปรับรูปหน้าที่ไหไนดี ร้อยไหมที่ใด

    ดี? กังนัมสถานพยาบาล


    คำตอบไม่ว่าจะเป็น ร้อยไหมหน้าเรียว เป็นวีไลน์แบบประเทศเกาหลี





    ลดอายุ หน้าเด็ก ไม่เจ็บ ไม่บอบช้ำ

    ไม่บวม หน้าเป็นวีเชฟ ลดเหนียง เหนียงกระชับสมปรารถนา

    ร้อยไหม เป็นยังไง

    การร้อยไหม เป็น


    ผิวหน้าที่ไม่กระชับ หย่อนยาน

    คล้อย ให้กลับมากระชับ หน้าเรียว เต่งตึง เข้ารูป วีเชฟได้สมปรารถนา








    ร้อยไหม วีเชฟ

  12. This Is Really Useful And Nice Information.
    This are such great articles. This articles can help you to make some new ideas. I appreciate for reading my blogs.

  13. his is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the excellent work.

  14. Cup youth tournament featuring Kevin D. The club's midfielder A Bruyne was founded in his native Belgium, where he invited the Spaniard to visit the game, and the following คาสิโนออนไลน์999 year Lavia joined City's academy and Has been voted the best player of the season in the under-23 team after leading the team to the title. The second Premier League has a degree in the Belgian U19 national team and admits to

  15. Manchester United forward Cristiano Ronaldo has admitted he and his team-mates have had to endure a difficult time following last week's humiliating defeat to Liverpool. As reported by Manchester Evening News.

    The 36-year-old scored one goal and one assist as the Red Devils defeated Tottenham Hotspur 3-0 in พนันกีฬาฟุตบอล the Premier League on Saturday. which is a return of good form by the Reds, the main rivals have attacked the house earlier

  16. The home team took the lead from Diego Sousa in the 12th minute but conceded two goals late in the first half to Rafael Veega, one of which was a penalty, before Bet. Rno Lopez scores สล็อตแตกง่าย to hammer the lid on the hosts' coffin in injury time in the second half. As a result, Gremio is now at risk of relegation after being second in the table with 26 points from 27 games.

  17. Lukaku has an ankle problem with Werner suffering a hamstring injury. and they are on a break to heal their injuries. Which is expected to return to help the agency after the international break, although "Sing the Blues" do not have both attacking รูเล็ตออนไลน์
    lines, but they have no problem with scoring, especially Reece James and Ben Chilve. L, two wing-backs who show their form hotly. Plus, the duo have scored a total of 6 goals in the last 4 league games.

  18. That's what Spurs have failed to do. After 10 league games, they are a team with just 71 accurate passes เว็บการพนันออนไลน์ into the 18-yard box, the sixth lowest number in the league, while No. 1 in the charts. This time, Manchester City have done 150 times together.

  19. Following Nuno's sacking, there were speculations that Antonio Conte was the new manager Spurs were about to pull in, and fans would be very happy if that did happen. Redknapp told Sky Sports.

    “Everyone knows that คาสิโนBETONE Conte is a world-class football manager. He's second to none. Born to be a true winner And it has proven many successes with Juventus, Chelsea, Inter Milan.”

  20. players from Manchester United have come in, making excuses from the week before, pouring into a rather bad team, while others will come from any club Let's have a look. ล็อตโต้-vip Goalkeeper: Aaron Rensdale (Arsenal) of "CR7" may not be a problem because the players take good care of their bodies, but for "El Matador has to say it might be too risky to use him twice in three days, plus a big game over the

  21. The sports media set Revealed that one of Conte's goals is to take Dusan Vlajovic, the pioneer of Fiorentina to join the army in January. Hoping to be a representative of Harry Kane that the Spurs may decide to sell on the market this winter. Because การพนันออนไลน์ otherwise you will lose him for free. Until next summer, it is said that Fiorentina executives have already had some talks with Spurs representatives about the deal within London.

  22. After being seen as one of the favorites to win the Ballon d'Or, the latest Lionel Messi spearheaded Paris Saint – Germain. He said that he did not think that he would receive an award this year. But he said that he had already won the biggest prize. That was his first trophy with Argentina's top team Lionel Messi, the famous เว็บพนันออนไลน์ Paris Saint-Germain striker. The billionaires of the French Ligue 1 club have said they are unlikely to win the 2021 Ballon d'Or award.

  23. This big match comes to follow that Cristiano Ronaldo and his Red Devils friends. Will be able to leverage the work to collect points to return to the path พนันบอลออนไลน์
    of the championship and to break the fierce form of the adversary. Who is the protagonist with a club record fee of 100 million pounds, such as Jack Grealish and many other superstars overflowing the team or not? Manchester City must be on fire. with a battle of dignity that neither side wants to be defeated

  24. Manchester United manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer is set to lead his team at the top of the game against Atalanta in the UEFA Champions League group F on Tuesday, November 2. Red Devils" just called morale back to the team again. After showing great form in the match invaded Tottenham Hotspur comfortable horseshoes on Saturday past. Causing the pressure situation of "Aunt Candy" to relax a lot, however, in the away game Atalanta, they do not เว็บพนันออนไลน์
    underestimate because if they lose to a team from the city of Bergamo. There is a chance to fall into 3rd place in the group and have to be stressed in the final match against Young Boys

  25. from a melee rhythm in the penalty area, the ball came into Mason Greenwood's way back to set for Cristiano Ronaldo to follow the water with the right side of the bike. Koi bounced คาสิโนสด to the floor through Juan Musso's hand. Squeezing the base of the far post, tucked into the bottom of the beautiful net, Manchester United came to the final

  26. The former Real Madrid defender has been injured again. and during his absence Their defense was like a broken dam.

    Although it has not yet been determined when Rafael Varane will return. But at least he is unlikely to be ready for the Manchester derby in the next few days for sure.

    Leicester scored four คาสิโนยูฟ่าเบ็ท goals, Liverpool five more in United without Varane - let's just guess what City can do.

  27. As a result, Lewandowski became the first player since November 2013 to score, assist. And failed to score a penalty in the same match in a Champions League คาสิโนออนไลน์เว็บตรง ​game, the last person before him to do so was Diego Costa, who did it while playing for Atletico Madrid in the match. with Austria Vienn

  28. Guardiola said: "Obviously it's very bad news for everyone, especially for him and his family. We all at Manchester เว็บคาสิโนอันดับ1 City wish him a speedy recovery. He probably knows that we are hoping for a speedy recovery, but really what's important isn't the time to heal."

  29. Aguero had worked with Guardiola at the Etihad for a while before his contract with Manchester City expired and joined Barcelona last summer. come But a few days ago, เว็บคาสิโนออนไลน์ the 33-year-old had a pain in his chest during the match and was quickly substituted off the field. Most recently, it was stated that he had to be rested for at least three months.

  30. Manchester United were two rounds behind but were leveled thanks to Cristiano Ronaldo's goals in stoppage time both in the first and second half. In the second half, their defensive game did not เครดิตฟรีไม่ต้องฝาก
    look as good as it should be. Which many see it because the French defender Raphael Varane was substituted from the 38th minute due to the fact that he appeared to have an injury.

  31. game in the second half after a few minutes, Jota slipped into a single pass to successfully pass the ball into the goal. But, unfortunately, VAR clearly pointed out that the ball was offside. เว็บไซต์ พนันออนไลน์
    And after that, Liverpool have the opportunity to be thrilled again. Both from falling into the shot with Salah's Oblak, Joel Matip's shot out of the frame and Jota's header in the 57th minute, there were important

  32. Cristiano Ronaldo has returned to Manchester United after leaving 12 years ago, helping the team score many important goals.
    As Gian Piero Gasperini puts it, พนันสล็อต he is one of the sharpest strikers of his generation. And more than half of his shots on target often end up in the bottom of the net.

  33. In that match, there was a moment when the referee gave a yellow card to Liverpool forward Diogo Jota from the moment he tried to approach the ball with Kieran Trippier, full-back "At Bear", but became raise your feet high Which this shot made Griezmann very dissatisfied because in the previous match that both of them สล็อตออนไลน์ฟรี
    duel The French forward had a shot that was intended to play the ball but turned out to be a high foot lift hit by Roberto Firmino that caused him to get a red card.

  34. However, on race day, it turned out that Maguire had a real name. But it wasn't very good for Manchester United as they lost 2-4 to Leicester and in the following games เว็บคาสิโน Maguire's overall performance was not so impressive that it made Many said he was the cause of many goals the team lost.

  35. Marouane Fellaini said when he learned that David Moyes was kicked out as Manchester United manager, he was devastated to the point of crying. Ready to say that in fact, if เกมคาสิโน the "Red Devils" give Moyes time, then he will be able to create a better team. Similar to when referred to as he is doing well with West Ham at the moment.

  36. According to The Telegraph, when Harry Maguire was playing against Leicester, he was actually not fit to play in the field. With still having to take a break for another 7-10 days together, during which Maguire has been heavily blamed for causing the team to lose many goals Harry Maguire, the captain of the Manchester team Lester United had to play in the English Premier League match that the club lost 2-4 to Leicester City on ไพ่แบล็คแจ็คออนไลน์
    October 16, although doctors estimate that he will need another 7-10 days to recover from the condition. Fit for playing, according to The Telegraph, the city's elite media.

  37. cards to a red card. Expelled from the field as well, Vitesse left 10 people, the visiting team left with only 9 สล็อตออนไลน์ people. Tanguy Ndombele came out of the single to see Marcus Schubert, the opponent's defense outside the penalty area. The local footballer shoots the ball. The referee indicated that the visitor deliberately used his back hand

  38. Shock happened during West Ham's European Cup draw with Genk on Wednesday when a Hammer's supporter cut an inch during the goal celebration. It's good to be คาสิโน treated in a timely manner. A West Ham United fan suffered a torn finger on the pitch during their UEFA Europa League Group H draw with Belgian side Genk 2. 2 on Thursday, November 4

  39. Manchester United legend Michael Silvest has defended the current Red Devils captain, Harry Maguire, who has been heavily criticized for his poor form that led to a series of defeats to his opponents. this season
    “This season has been a very difficult year for Maguire as he has just returned from injury คาสิโนสด and faced a poor overall form of the team. Ultimately, it has had a devastating effect on our confidence that it has made many mistakes,” Nam Dupa told MyBettingSites.

  40. Alan Shearer has stated that among the current Premier League managers, Liverpool boss Jurgen Klopp is เกมสล็อต the one he would most like to work with. Ready to believe that Phil Foden will be able to become a world-class footballer.

  41. A West Ham United fan suffered a torn finger on the pitch during their UEFA Europa League Group H draw with คาสิโนสด Belgian side Genk 2. 2 On Thursday, November 4, the hosts took the lead in the fourth minute before the visitors netted two goals from Said Benrahma in 59 and 82 minutes.

  42. While coach Didier Deschamps, "Chicken Badge", despite leading the team เกมคาสิโน
    to the Nations League title, with a disappointing performance at Euro 2020, where they were eliminated from the last 16 by foot. of Switzerland was also in a stressful situation.

  43. “At the next ball, or 20 seconds after the previous one, There was a diagonal throw of the ball at him. คาสิโนสด
    He tried to control the ball by using his chest. And I jumped and kicked like Bruce Lee at him. I aimed at his throat. At that time his posture was almost like a backflip and his neck almost broke.”

  44. Mohamed Salah has scored in the first five away league games of the season for Liverpool every match by Egyptian คาสิโนauto footballers He is only the second player to do so since Thierry Henry in 2001/02, with the Gunners legend missing in his sixth away game of the season, only Manchester City. (80) And Chelsea (66) who have taken more points

  45. In the case of Victor Lindelof, the Swedish centre-back that the physical condition is not perfect Will be สล็อตออนไลน์เว็บตรง
    ready to come back to help the team in the Manchester derby game? But I can't promise you anything," concluded Solcha.

  46. Manchester United forward Edison Cavani has announced he wants to take part in the Manchester derby against Manchester City on Saturday, according to reports. Manchester Evening News
    The Uruguay คาสิโนยูฟ่าเบท national team striker just scored 1 goal in the game that the Red Devils defeated Tottenham last week. And they will have a major battle against Pep Guardiola's squad this weekend.

  47. Over the years, many have cited Manchester City's team condition, style of play and overall performance far superior to their city rivals. Especially since Guardiola took over the reins of Manchester City in 2016, Manchester United has always performed particularly well in Manchester derby matches. Especially the คาสิโนออนไลน์เครดิตฟรี
    last four league games in which Manchester United have won 3 times, while the other one ended in a draw, and both teams have a duel on Saturday, November 6.

  48. Fans of "Red Army" are relieved when they know the statistics when Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, the beloved boss, made the team face Pep Guardiola when "Aunt Ole" won over the pedigree เกมสล็อตออนไลน์ coach. Bull is fierce to 4 out of 8 games that meet in all competitions. Send him to be the manager with the highest win rate, the boss "Sailboat" in at least 5 meetings (50%).

  49. Betway Casino and Sportsbook Review | JamBase
    The Betway Casino 경기도 출장안마 in the U.S. 광주 출장안마 isn't 목포 출장마사지 just for sports betting enthusiasts, but for 창원 출장마사지 any serious gambler looking to use it in their next casino venture. 강릉 출장샵